ADA Compliance & Defense Lawyer Update: 99 ADA Lawsuits Dismissed as Fraudulent and Malicious
November 21, 2017 1:21pm
By Jim Butler and the Global Hospitality Group®
Hotel Lawyers | Authors of www.HotelLawBlog.com
21 November 2017
JMBM’s ADA Compliance and Defense team, led by my partner Marty Orlick, continues to help hotels and other businesses achieve compliance under the Americans With Disabilities Act (ADA), and is actively defending numerous ADA lawsuits brought against our clients.
Today, he shares one of the stranger tales of serial ADA litigation and describes how the judicial system in New Mexico stopped the plaintiff and her lawyer from filing frivolous and malicious ADA lawsuits.
New Mexico Judge Dismisses 99 ADA Lawsuits as Fraudulent and Malicious Entertains Sanction Motions
by Martin H. Orlick, Chair, JMBM’s ADA Compliance & Defense Group
On October 26, 2017, a judge dismissed 99 ADA lawsuits, ordered an in forma pauperis plaintiff (a person without funds to pursue the cost of a lawsuit) to pay filing fees of $38,300 and authorized the defendants to file fee and sanction motions.
Surely, this plaintiff’s lawyer rues the day she answered an ad on Craigslist looking for a civil rights lawyer to file ADA litigation in her jurisdiction.
What’s going on?
A Strange Set of Circumstances
The Arizona-based organization, Litigation Management and Financial Services, Inc. (LMFS), a descendant of the notorious ADA plaintiffs’ group Advocates for Individuals with Disabilities, used Craigslist, indeed.com and other online media to find and engage disabled plaintiffs to file ADA lawsuits, and lawyers to represent them. The online advertisements resulted in hundreds of ADA lawsuits filed against businesses in New Mexico, Nevada, Colorado and Utah.
It is also how a disabled plaintiff and her lawyer came to file 99 ADA lawsuits in New Mexico, alleging each defendant’s business violated the ADA and related anti-discrimination laws. According to court documents, the deal LMFS made with this plaintiff and her counsel, worked like this:
What the Court Learned
When the Court discovered that the plaintiff and her lawyer had filed 99 cases without paying filing fees (requesting fee deferrals based on the plaintiff’s in forma pauperis status), the Article III Judge instructed the Magistrate Judge to investigate the circumstances. The plaintiff’s counsel appeared at the hearing held by the Magistrate, but the plaintiff missed her bus and failed to appear (despite allegedly appearing at the sites of the 99 businesses she sued). Although the Court continued the hearing to a later date, the plaintiff’s counsel took the opportunity to disclose the financial arrangement, including the fee agreement, she had entered into with LMFS in which LMFS agreed to pay all costs of the lawsuits, including filing fees. The Court ordered the plaintiff’s counsel to produce a copy of her funding contract with LMFS, and the plaintiff and her counsel were ordered to appear and testify at an Order to Show Cause hearing into the fee waivers and the merits of the case.
At the continued hearing, the Court examined the plaintiff and her lawyer about the merits of the lawsuit and their relationship with LMFS. The plaintiff conceded that she did not visit a number of the businesses she sued and testified that she believed the lawsuits were “frivolous”. The plaintiff’s counsel was examined intensely about her fee sharing agreement with LMFS and LMFS’ agreement to pay all costs, including filing fees. The counsel conceded the fact that the plaintiff had the financial resources to pay her filing fees through the LMFS fee sharing agreement.
The Magistrate’s Report, Findings of Fact and Recommendations
The Magistrate Judge issued a report of findings and recommendations, finding that the lawsuits were malicious and should be dismissed. The report recommended that the plaintiff pay filing fees of nearly $35,000. The report left open the issues of sanctions, defense fees and costs.
The Trial Court’s Dismissal
Adopting the Magistrate’s Report, Findings of Fact and Recommendations, the trial court dismissed the lawsuits as frivolous and malicious and ordered the plaintiff to pay filing fees of $38,300. The Court authorized the defendants to file motions for fees and sanctions against the plaintiff and her counsel, as well as third-party complaints perhaps against LMFS.
Who are the Victims?
Some suggest that these lawyers and plaintiffs who answered ads on Craigslist are the unwitting victims of LMFS, and did not intend to file malicious litigation. But abusive ADA litigation cannot be condoned under any circumstances. For decades, certain ADA plaintiff groups (though, not all) have attacked countless business owners, large and small, over often-minor infractions that could be quickly resolved. They have clogged an overworked court system with unnecessary litigation. And, in their quest to make an easy buck, they have done a tremendous disservice to the disabled community, which deserves better representation.
Martin H. Orlick is one of the top ADA defense lawyers in the country. He has helped hotel, restaurant, retail and other commercial property owners defend more than 600 ADA cases. In addition to defending lawsuits and governmental investigations, Marty’s team of ADA specialists focuses on enterprise-wide ADA compliance and litigation prevention, including facilities, website and operational compliance. He is also is a senior member of the law firm’s Global Hospitality Group®, a partner in the real estate department, and a member of the American College of Real Estate Lawyers (ACREL). For more information about ADA compliance and defense, contact Marty Orlick at 415.984.9667 or firstname.lastname@example.org.
This is Jim Butler, author of www.HotelLawBlog.com and hotel lawyer, signing off. Please contact us if you would like to discuss any issues or development that affect your hotel interests. We would like to see if our experience might help you create value or avoid unnecessary pitfalls. Who’s your hotel lawyer?
Tags: jim butler,
global hospitality group,
Jim Butler is a founding partner of JMBM and JMBM’s Global Hospitality Group® which provides business and legal advice to hotel owners, developers and investors. This advice covers hotel purchase, sale, development, financing, franchise, management, labor & employment, litigation, ADA, IP, EB-5 matters any many other areas.
Jim is recognized as one of the top hotel lawyers in the world and has led the Global Hospitality Group® in more than $71 billion of hotel transactions and more than 3,800 hotel properties located around the globe.
Jim’s group has advised on more than 100 EB-5 projects, closed more than $1.5 billion of EB-5 financing, and sourced more than half of that for our clients.
Contact: Jim Butler
A Top Priority in 2018: 7 Steps to Achieve Hotel Website Accessibility and ADA Compliance
California Labor & Employment Law Update: Key Changes in 2017 and What’s Slated for 2018
Homeland Security Warns Against Threats to US Infrastructure
Resort Fee Litigation Advisory Group: How to Avoid Litigation on Resort Fees and Other Mandatory Hotel Charges
Hotel Lawyer: Tips on Negotiating Your Annual Hotel Budget
Resort Fee Litigation Advisory Group: How Resort Fees Became an Explosive $2.7 Billion Issue
Resort Fee Litigation Advisory Group: National Task Force of 47 Attorneys General Goes After Resort Fees
Resort Fee Litigation Advisory Group: The FTC Takes Aim at Hotel Resort Fees (Again) - The FTC 2017 Report
Resort Fee Litigation Advisory Group: Impending Eruption of Litigation over Resort Fees?
Hotel Lawyer: Tax Alert for Partnerships and LLCs
EB-5 Finance Lawyer: President Trump's Budget Deal Includes Extension of EB-5 Through 12-8-17
EB-5 Financing Lawyer: What JMBM Does to Help Developers With EB-5 Construction Financing
EB-5 Financing Lawyer: Why You Do NOT Want to Form Your Own Regional Center
EB-5 Financing Lawyer: The 5 Questions Every Developer is Asking About EB-5 Financing
JMBM's Global Hospitality Group Announces the Publication of an EB-5 Handbook for Developers
EB-5 Financing Lawyer: EB-5 Construction Financing Term Sheet for Top Developers
EB-5 Financing Lawyer: FAQs: Essentials of EB-5 Construction Financing for Developers
EB-5 Financing Lawyer: More than $1.5 Billion of EB-5 Construction Financing Closed for JMBM Clients
EB-5 Finance Lawyer: Are Hotels Still the Darling of EB-5 Financing?
EB-5 Finance Lawyer: Tips to Avoid the 6 Most Common Mistakes Developers Make With EB-5
Please login or register to post a comment.